Monday, September 28, 2015

Data Privacy and Anti-Money Laundering Rules on a Transatlantic Head-On Course

In the digital age, financial data is both a commercial tool and a means of detecting criminal activity. This leaves multinational financial institutions, especially those that operate in both the United States and the European Union, at risk for fines and litigation.

The dual nature of financial data means that it is simultaneously governed by two regimes: anti-money-laundering and counter-terrorism finance laws that seek to protect the financial system from fraud, crime, and political violence; and data protection and privacy laws that seek to protect an individual's identity and choices from government and private abuse.

Neither set of regulations adequately addresses financial data's dual role. This means that multinational banks can find it difficult to comply with one without violating the other — particularly given that different countries incentivize banks to prioritize different regimes. It is time for the financial sector to take this opportunity to establish industry standards that turn client privacy into a business asset. This will mitigate the operational risks arising from sometimes-contradictory national AML and data protection requirements.

There is some harmony between U.S. and E.U. risk-based laws intended to root out money laundering and terrorist financing. Privacy is a different story.

The E.U.'s comprehensive rules-based system protects privacy as a human right. The law is meant to be applied with limited exceptions. Meanwhile, the U.S. protects privacy by sector and typically treats consumer data as property, with civil rights set by case law. Multinational banks find themselves balancing different demands on the data they collect from their clients, which causes problems in AML compliance.

The legal ambiguities have their greatest impact with cross-border data flows. This year, the E.U.'s fourth money-laundering directive legalized group-wide suspicious activity reports and supporting data and included data protection provisions that safeguard these transfers.

Couching data protection within AML operations provides a trail of accountability. But U.S. and E.U. multinationals still face obstacles since they do not, and cannot, allow unfettered data access among all of their affiliates and subsidiaries. That's because network systems and software are often incompatible and some data protection and disclosure laws forbid trans-border access. In addition, in the U.S., banks are forbidden to share SARs with their foreign branches and affiliates because of disclosure restrictions, which make it difficult to implement group-wide compliance programs. Thus, AML compliance officers must circumvent technological and legal barriers in one jurisdiction to investigate or complete reports for another and risk penalties for doing so.

Conflicting Accountabilities
One thing that data protection and AML officials do share is an affinity for enforcing accountability with fines and litigation. In 2014, the U.S. levied $13 billion in fines against banks for AML violations, including European firms. Europe also issued millions in AML penalties. On the privacy side, a bevy of U.S. state and federal agencies enforce corporate privacy regulations, but there are generous exceptions for AML and national security. The E.U. Data Protection Directive, meanwhile, allows for a wide range of national penalties and actions for data violations, but it also contained exemptions for AML under the umbrella of the "public interest."

The inclusion of data protection in the Money-Laundering Directive closes many of the E.U.'s AML data loopholes. The requirement for group-wide data sharing makes it clear that AML processes and procedures must include privacy standards no matter where they operate. And soon, the E.U.'s General Data Protection Regulation will allow either 2% or 5% global annual turnover or €100 million in fines, which incentivizes banks to take these rules seriously.

Yet given the current trend of holding AML compliance officials personally accountable for violations as well as the broader regulatory effort to instill a cultureof ethical responsibility into business, it's likely that AML priorities will remain many banks' top priority. The AML/privacy dichotomy will prompt many compliance officials to weigh their own welfare against that of their firms.

An experienced AML officer made this point explicitly in May at the Association of Certified Anti-Money Laundering Specialists' 11th Annual AML and Financial Crime conference in London when a fellow panelist challenged him about using data that might violate data privacy and protection rules:

"But you might get a 5% global fine!"

"Yes, I know, but I am not putting myself in jeopardy."

Few compliance officers would disagree.

A Multidisciplinary Approach to Best Practices
It is in no one's best interest for AML and data privacy regulations to maintain their transatlantic collision course. To navigate this new environment, financial services officials need to change their attitudes about data privacy.

For many, it is understandably easier to view countering illicit finance and terrorism as a public good. The threat of state surveillance or corporate data misuse might seem benign in comparison.

But financial institutions must reevaluate their ethical responsibilities to client data. The political climate has shifted, and the public expects private corporations to consciously balance national security with individual rights.

Moreover, banks' entitled attitude toward client data — and their attempts to monetize it as an asset — are not helping their public image. Clients care about privacy both in the U.S. and E.U. Firms that respond to this demand and market their commitments to privacy effectively will gain reputational trust and simultaneously lower their risks for data protection violations with Europe.

Ultimately, it is big banks' responsibility to establish data privacy best practices in the context of their AML duties. At the global and regional levels, some conflicts could be mitigated by establishing regular dialogues among government, regulatory and law enforcement officials. From these deliberations, banks should establish best practices for products and jurisdictions. To avoid informational and educational stovepipes, they should do so with a multidisciplinary approach that involves information security specialists, privacy and AML professionals, and senior executives who possess overlapping knowledge and skillsets.

The duality of data in finance cannot be eliminated. However, the risks among national security, privacy, and business can be improved — with a concerted effort on the part of the industry.

Expert says: ‘Senior managers' regulations will escalate contradictions between anti-money laundering and data protection rules’

New rules aimed at increasing the accountability of senior managers at financial institutions in the UK "will exacerbate the conflict" that already exists between anti-money laundering duties and compliance with data privacy rules, an expert has said.
Senior staff at banks, building societies and regulated investment companies could face fines, disqualifications and potentially, jail time, for failing to perform their duties properly under the Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SM&CR) that will apply from 7 March 2016. A separate Senior Insurance Managers' Regime (SIMR) will come into force on 1 January next year.
Financial regulation expert Michael Ruck of Pinsent Masons, the law firm behind Out-Law.com, said he echoed concerns expressed by US academic Dr Michelle Frasher last month about the discord that can exist between compliance with US and EU anti-money laundering (AML) rules and the EU's data protection regime.
In an article published by American Banker, Dr Michelle said "an experienced AML officer" had admitted at a conference in London earlier this year that they would risk their employer being fined up to 5% of their global turnover, as is proposed under new EU data protection rules being negotiated, by "using data that might violate data privacy and protection rules" to meet their AML responsibilities. He said he would do that so as not to put themselves "in jeopardy", she said. The academic said most other AML officers would also adopt that view.
"This is clearly an issue financial institutions and money laundering reporting and compliance officers are currently considering very carefully," Ruck said. "The potential conflict between the interests of the firm and the individual compliance officer may be inherent in the role, and has been for some time, but will be exacerbated by the senior managers' regime being introduced for banks and insurers in the UK."
"The banking regime reverses the burden of proof onto an individual who has responsibility for an area of the bank in which a breach of the regulatory regime occurs, making individual accountability an extremely hot topic. This may reflect the approach of the AML officer referenced in Dr Michelle Frasher's article," he said.
Ruck said that banks must take steps to "fully understand" how AML and data protection rules apply to them, both in the UK and internationally. They should also "ensure their staff understand the regimes, put in place senior management responsibility for compliance and, in circumstances where the two regimes may appear to be at odds, seek advice on how to address this conflict".
"There is some provision for any such conflict to be resolved in the EU's new Anti-Money Laundering Directive but with the various international regimes and international regulatory bodies often involved, these conflicts will continue to arise," Ruck said.

Thursday, July 16, 2015

U.S. charges 9 people for offshore $6.5 mln pump-and-dump scheme

A California man who has had repeated run-ins with U.S. securities regulators was indicted along with eight other people on Tuesday for engaging in an offshore pump-and-dump scheme that generated over $6.5 million in profits.

In an indictment unsealed in federal court in Alexandria, Virginia, Harold Gallison, 57, was accused of engaging in securities fraud and participating in conspiracies to commit wire fraud and money laundering.

offshore
offshore

Deutsche Bank Moscow probe spreads to UK

The UK financial watchdog is in the early stages of an investigation into whether Deutsche Bank breached anti money-laundering laws for its Moscow clients, adding an extra flank to a burgeoning international probe.

The Financial Conduct Authority’s involvement adds to inquiries by at least two other bodies around the world into so-called mirror trades executed in London and Moscow by the bank. New York’s banking regulator asked Deutsche for information about a failed offer to bribe a Moscow employee as part of its investigation.

The FCA’s attention — which was sparked by Deutsche Bank itself reporting the matter to both the UK watchdog and its German equivalent, BaFin — is at an early stage. The bank remains under so-called “special measures” instigated by the FCA after a slew of regulatory issues, including the Libor-rigging scandal.

Deutsche Bank, the FCA and BaFin declined to comment.

Deutsche Bank
Deutsche Bank


The matter also has the potential to morph into a criminal investigation as it is on the radar of criminal prosecutors at the UK’s Serious Fraud Office, which said it was aware of the allegations. It declined to comment further.

The trades under scrutiny by the FCA first came to light following a request from the Russian central bank late last year. Deutsche Bank then undertook an internal probe looking at trades carried out over a period of four years ending in early 2015. Last month it said it had placed several individuals from its Moscow unit on leave.

The trades in question involve securities bought in roubles through Deutsche Bank in Moscow by Russian clients, at the same time the bank bought the same securities in western currencies from various entities through its London business.

The practice is known as mirror trades and regulators are concerned that it could be used by Russian clients to bypass money-laundering rules to illegally move funds out of the country. They are also scrutinising how quickly Deutsche Bank reported the suspicious trades.

The matter is yet another conduct issue with which John Cryan, who took over as chief executive this month, must grapple.

The bank paid a record $2.5bn to US and UK regulators in April to settle allegations that its traders manipulated the Libor rate. Nearly half of the FCA’s £227m portion of that fine included a penalty for misleading the regulator.

Meanwhile, a BaFin report into Libor-rigging found that Deutsche Bank’s senior management allegedly acted negligently, and its former co-head Anshu Jain may have knowingly misled the German central bank — allegations Mr Jain and the bank strenuously deny.

BaFin is due to make its final determinations on potential supervisory measures following Deutsche Bank’s formal response to its report.

Singapore takes tough stance on financial crime: anti-money laundering

In response to queries on its anti-money laundering and countering the financing of terrorism regime, the Monetary Authority of Singapore said the Republic is firmly committed to maintaining its status as a clean and trusted financial centre.

SINGAPORE: Singapore’s regime for anti-money laundering and countering the financing of terrorism (AML/CFT) meets global standards - and the central bank's regulation and supervision of the financial sector has been evaluated by the International Monetary Fund as “among the best globally” the Monetary Authority of Singapore said on Wednesday (Jul 15).

It issued a statement in response to recent queries over its AML/CFT regime. The MAS said Singapore is firmly committed to maintaining its status as a clean and trusted financial centre. The country has "no tolerance for its financial system to be used as a refuge or conduit for illicit fund flows", MAS stated.

Its AML/CFT regime comprises four key elements, namely, strict regulation, rigorous supervision, effective enforcement, and close cross-border co-operation.

MAS said all financial institutions in Singapore are required to conduct stringent checks on the sources of their customer funds, including customer due diligence and regular account reviews. Financial institutions are required to monitor for and report any suspicious transactions.

financial system
financial system


On its part, MAS undertakes regular reviews to strengthen its regulatory regime and to mitigate emerging risks, it said. It also conducts regular on-site inspections to ensure that banks and other financial institutions comply with AML/CFT laws and regulations. And when breaches are found, MAS will take enforcement actions, ranging from formal warnings, reprimands, restriction on operations, to financial penalties and revocation of licences.

Between April 2013 and March 2014, MAS said it conducted 83 AML/CFT inspections, issued nine supervisory warnings and reprimands, restricted the operations of six financial institutions, and revoked the licences of two remittance agents. It also fined five financial institutions for breaches of AML/CFT requirements.

In the global fight against money laundering and terrorism-funding, MAS said Singapore authorities have established effective channels to facilitate international co-operation and exchange of information.

The central banks adds that taking a tough stance on financial crime and keeping the financial sector clean is critical to Singapore's reputation and development as an international financial centre.

Monday, July 13, 2015

Govt starts work on extending anti-money laundering provisions to professions

The government has started work on expanding anti-money laundering obligations to professionals including lawyers and accountants as the number of suspicious transactions reported to law enforcement agencies more than triples since legislation came into effect.

Ministry of Justice officials have started early work on considering a second tranche of legislative reform that would extend anti-money laundering requirements to professions and businesses dealing in high-value goods, such as lawyers, accountants, conveyancing practitioners and real estate agents, Justice Minister Amy Adams said at the Asia/Pacific Group on Money Laundering annual meeting in Auckland.

Ministry of Justice officials are considering legislation that will extend anti-money laundering requirements to professions including lawyers and real estate agents.
Ministry of Justice officials are considering legislation that will extend anti-money laundering requirements to professions including lawyers and real estate agents.

Romania Freezes Premier’s Assets as Graft Charges Brought

Romanian Prime Minister Victor Ponta’s future is in jeopardy after anti-corruption prosecutors formally charged him and froze his assets.

Ponta, premier since 2012, was charged with forgery, money laundering and complicity in tax fraud, according to a statement Monday on the Anti-Corruption Directorate’s website. The case, announced in June, covers his time as a lawyer before he took office and also involves ex-Transport Minister Dan Sova. Both deny wrongdoing. Ponta didn’t comment after meeting prosecutors.

“There will be mounting pressure on Ponta to resign in the coming days,” said Otilia Dhand, a Brussels-based analyst for Teneo Intelligence. “While he may still survive this particular crisis, the odds that he’ll serve a full term as prime minister are diminishing fast.”

Victor Ponta
Victor Ponta


Ponta, 42, is the first sitting head of government to face criminal charges in Romania and was urged again Monday by President Klaus Iohannis to step down. Adrian Nastase, ex-prime minister of Romania, a European Union and NATO member, was handed a two-year jail sentence in 2012 for illegally raising funds for a presidential campaign.

The leu was 0.3 percent stronger at 4.4297 against the euro at 2:56 p.m. in Bucharest, recouping losses that followed the prosecutors’ statement, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. Yields on government Eurobonds due 2024 fell five basis points to 2.75 percent as Greece’s bailout calmed fears over Romanian banks’ exposure to Athens-based lenders.

‘Reasonable Suspicion’

Ponta is accused of forging documents to justify income while he had a private legal practice, with the help of a law firm owned by Sova. Prosecutors said Monday that “there are data and evidence showing there’s a reasonable suspicion” the allegations are valid. They’ll speak to him again in August.

Ponta, who’s weathered plagiarism accusations and come back from a presidential-election defeat in the past, quit Sunday as leader of the ruling Social Democratic Party.

He returned last week from Turkey after knee surgery, having survived a confidence vote last month in parliament, where he also retained his immunity to repel a separate conflict-of-interest probe.